Cast No. 17 The Distributor Dilemma: Scale Comes With a Price

Every small fishing company dreams about the same thing. A big distributor picks up your line. Suddenly your products are everywhere. Thousands of dealers have access. Orders become larger. You spend less time chasing accounts. It feels like the moment when you finally move from being a small company… To becoming a real player. At least that’s the picture everyone imagines. The reality is a little more complicated.

Distribution Is a Multiplier

Here’s the first thing every manufacturer needs to understand. A distributor does not create demand. They multiply demand that already exists. That’s an important distinction. A distributor can make your product available. They can put your products in front of retailers. They can make ordering easier. But they cannot replace the hard work of building a brand. If customers aren’t asking for your product… More availability doesn’t automatically solve the problem. It just means more people can ignore it.

The Dream of the Big Purchase Order

There is nothing quite like receiving a large purchase order. A small company sees that number and thinks: “We made it.” But then the business side kicks in. That order has a cost. Manufacturing. Materials. Packaging. Shipping. Terms. Production time. Cash tied up. A large order can create a strange problem. You can be selling more than ever…

And still feel like you’re running out of money. Revenue feels good. Cash flow keeps the lights on.

Someone Has to Make Money in the Middle

Every time a product changes hands, someone needs margin. That’s not a bad thing. It’s business. The manufacturer needs margin. The distributor needs margin. The retailer needs margin. Everyone in the chain has a role. The challenge is making sure there is enough value created for everyone involved. Because if the numbers don’t work at the beginning… They won’t magically work when volume increases.

The Loss of Control

This is the part nobody talks about enough. When you sell direct to customers, you hear everything. You know what people love. You know what they dislike. You know what questions they ask. You see the reviews. You have the conversations. Distribution creates distance. Sometimes that’s good. It allows a company to grow. But distance also means losing some of the direct connection that helped build the company. You have to create new systems to stay close to the customer.

The Relationship Matters

A good distributor is worth their weight in gold. They understand the market. They help retailers. They create efficiency. They can open doors that would take years to open yourself. But like any relationship… The right fit matters. The wrong distributor can create problems. Expectations don’t match. Communication breaks down. Products don’t get the attention you expected. And suddenly you have inventory moving through a system… But not necessarily toward customers.

The Question Every Company Has to Answer

The question isn’t: “Can I get a distributor?” The question is: “Is distribution the right next step for my business?” Sometimes the answer is yes. Sometimes direct-to-consumer is the better path. Sometimes a hybrid approach makes the most sense. The best companies understand that there is no single formula. There is only the strategy that fits where they are today.

What I’ve Learned

Early on, I thought the biggest opportunity was getting more people to sell Ebb N Flow products. Now I think differently. The biggest opportunity is creating enough demand that the right partners want to help us grow. Because the strongest relationships aren’t built from desperation. They’re built from value.

One Last Cast…

Distribution is not the finish line. It’s another tool. A hammer can build a house. But swinging a hammer without a plan doesn’t accomplish much. The same is true with distribution. It can accelerate a great business. It can also expose weaknesses in a struggling one. The goal isn’t simply to get bigger. The goal is to build something strong enough that when opportunity arrives…

You’re ready for it. Because in business, the biggest wave isn’t always the one you chase. Sometimes it’s the one you are prepared to ride.

Until next cast...

- Dave Erdly
Founder, Ebb N Flow Outdoors


Question for everyone in the outdoor industry: For anyone who's worked with a distributor: what do you wish you'd known before you signed?
Previous post

Leave a comment